How to Cancel Your Erie Auto Insurance Policy in 6 Easy Steps (2023)

Based in Erie, Pennsylvania, Erie offers auto insurance to drivers in 12 states and Washington, D.C. According to the insurance provider, more than 90 percent of its customers stay with them year after year. If you have an Erie car insurance policy that no longer meets your needs, don’t feel bad about canceling and switching car insurance companies.

With this handy car insurance quote comparison tool, you can compare coverage options and auto insurance rates from the top-rated car insurance companies. It can help you find a plan that works better for your new circumstances. Rest assured that there are no sign-ups, fees, or credit checks.

Erie Cancellation Policy

While Erie hopes to retain its policyholders, the company honors all cancellation requests. To cancel your car insurance with Erie, you’ll need to reach out to a local Erie agent via phone, via mail, or in person. You can ask for your cancellation to take effect immediately or at a later date to avoid a lapse in coverage.

When you get a hold of an agent, be prepared to share your name, policy number, and desired date of termination. Fortunately, you won’t have to pay a cancellation fee when you do so. Also, if you paid for your policy up front, you may be eligible for a prorated refund in which Erie will refund any unused portions.

Step 1: Look Up the Renewal Date

If you have it in your head that you want to cancel your Erie auto insurance policy, you may be tempted to do so right away. However, if you cancel your current plan as close to your renewal date as possible, you can avoid a gap in coverage, which can be a serious issue if a police officer pulls you over or you get into a car accident.

Canceling near your renewal date may also make it easier to switch car insurance companies and enroll in new coverage. To find your renewal date, log in to your online account at erieinsurance.com. You can also look at your auto insurance identification card, which may be printed out and kept in your vehicle’s glove box or downloaded from the Erie website.

See More: Cheap Car Insurance

Step 2: Compare Car Insurance Quotes

Before you terminate your Erie auto insurance plan, it’s in your best interest to shop around and find the ideal coverage for your particular budget and needs. If you lead a busy life and don’t have time to browse countless websites and compare car insurance options, don’t worry.

That’s where Insurify comes in. You can use this intuitive tool to explore various auto insurance quotes from a variety of car insurance companies, like State Farm, Progressive, GEICO, Allstate, and many other large and small providers. Once you find an offer you like, Insurify will direct you to the company’s website so you can enroll.

See More: Best and Worst Sites to Compare Car Insurance

Erie Quotes vs. Competitors

Step 3: Think about Why You’re Leaving Erie

In a perfect world, your car insurance plan would work for you indefinitely, not just for one year or three years. The reality, however, is that your needs and priorities are bound to change over time and warrant a new policy. Before you leave Erie auto insurance, take the time to think about your motives for doing so.

Maybe you’re moving to a state that Erie doesn’t service. Or perhaps you prefer a larger car insurance company or want to lower your monthly premiums on comprehensive coverage. Another reason for canceling may be to bundle your auto policy with another insurance product, such as homeowners insurance, renters insurance, life insurance, or business insurance.

See More: Best Car Insurance Companies

Step 4: Secure a New Policy

Once you’ve found the perfect new auto insurance policy with some help from Insurify, be sure to enroll as soon as you can, before your Erie renewal date. Since it’s illegal to drive without liability insurance in most states, this is vital. Locking in a new car insurance plan prior to canceling can also protect you financially in the event of an at-fault accident.

Put simply, securing a new policy before you terminate with Erie will make your life easier. It can save you a great deal of money, stress, and headaches down the road. Thankfully, Insurify makes the enrollment process a breeze.

Step 5: Cancel Your Erie Policy

If you’ve already finalized a new car insurance plan with some help from Insurify and wish to cancel your Erie auto insurance policy, you’ll have to get a hold of a local Erie insurance agent^[1]. No matter if you contact them by phone, via mail, or in person, you’ll need an official written notice that includes:

• Your name, address, and phone number

• Your Erie policy number

• Your Social Security number and date of birth

• Your driver’s license number

• The date you’d like your policy to end

• Your dated signature

Here are more details on each cancellation method.

Phone

To cancel your car insurance coverage by phone, call Erie customer care at 1 (800) 458-0811 any weekday from 8 a.m. to 11 p.m. ET or Saturday from 9 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. ET. You can select option 4 or stay on the line. If you have your local agent’s number on hand, call them directly to save time.

Mail

You can also bypass the phone and send your written notice to the Erie Insurance headquarters at:

Erie Insurance Group
100 Erie Insurance Place
Erie, PA 16530

To allow ample time for shipping, processing, and delays, try to send your letter a few weeks before you’d like your policy to end.

In Person

If you prefer a more traditional in-person cancellation, visit a local Erie insurance branch. These branches can be found on the Erie website and are located in Indiana, Kentucky, Maryland, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Virginia, West Virginia, Wisconsin, and Washington, D.C.

See More: Compare Car Insurance

Step 6: Follow Up on Your Refund

Just like any other car insurance company, Erie is in business to make money. Therefore, your refund may not be on their priority list, even if you’ve been a long-time policyholder and canceled on good terms.

If you know you’re owed a refund because of the way you paid for your policy, be sure to contact a local agent if you don’t receive it a few weeks after your termination. Since your refund may be hundreds of dollars, don’t forget about it. Follow up until you receive the prorated amount you know you’re entitled to.

Canceling Your Erie Policy

No matter your age or stage in life, canceling your Erie car insurance plan and switching to a different policy with a new provider can be tedious and time-consuming to say the least. That’s why our car insurance comparison tool was created. You can use it to find the ideal car insurance coverage that meets your new circumstances. It’s free and doesn’t require a sign-up.

Frequently Asked Questions